Short answer: Ask these 12 questions before you sign: who owns the accounts, what access is needed, what is guaranteed, what changes in 30 days, and how to leave. Score each answer 0, 1 or 2. Twenty or more of 24 is a safe signing range, and a 0 on questions 1 to 3 is a stop.
Last updated: November 2026

What these 12 questions are and how the scoring works
The 12 questions below each get 0, 1 or 2 points, for 24 in total, and the order is by how much a bad answer can cost you, not by topic. If you want to confirm you need an agency first, run the tests in 10 signs you need an SEO agency, and if you are comparing firms, start from the best SEO agencies in the United States hub. We sell SEO, AEO and GEO at GCL Marketing, so use these questions on us too.
| # | Ask this | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Who will own our Search Console, Analytics, Business Profile and hosting accounts, and our content? | Stop if 0 |
| 2 | What access do you need on day one, and at what level? | Stop if 0 |
| 3 | Do you guarantee any ranking, traffic or AI result? | Stop if 0 |
| 4 | What will you change in the first 30 days, in order? | Score 0 to 2 |
| 5 | Show me the Search Console data behind one past result for a business like mine. | Score 0 to 2 |
| 6 | Which Google documents does your advice rely on, and where do you disagree with them? | Score 0 to 2 |
| 7 | How will you measure our visibility in AI answers, and what can you not measure? | Score 0 to 2 |
| 8 | If we cancel, what is the notice period, what do we keep, and what happens to the pages and links? | Score 0 to 2 |
| 9 | Who does the work, and is any of it outsourced or done by AI without review? | Score 0 to 2 |
| 10 | What does the first report look like, and which number should move by day 90? | Score 0 to 2 |
| 11 | What would you say no to, and what kind of clients do you turn down? | Score 0 to 2 |
| 12 | Who is my day-to-day contact, and how many accounts do they carry? | Score 0 to 2 |
Twelve questions, 0 to 2 points each, 24 maximum. Order is by cost of a bad answer, highest first.
What every question list says, and what it misses
The top lists agree on a short set of basics: ask about process, reporting, case studies, pricing and contract terms, and avoid anyone who guarantees rankings. We read SEO.com’s 38 questions, That! Company’s list and Search Engine Journal’s 32 questions on November 2, 2026. They give you questions but not a way to score the answers, they disagree on counts and contract advice (table below), and none mention what Google changed in its own hiring guidance in June 2026.
| Source (read Nov 2, 2026) | Question count | Contract advice | Price or timeline claim |
|---|---|---|---|
| SEO.com | 38, grouped by theme | Contracts of six to twelve months are typical in the author’s experience | No prices; results in 3 to 6 months, sometimes 12, unsourced |
| That! Company | Headline says 10, headings list 13 | Month-to-month, from a vendor that sells it | $500 to $7,500 a month, unsourced |
| Search Engine Journal | 32, page dated May 2017 | Warns against long contracts sold on potential | No figures |
None of the three cites a study for its numbers, and none of the versions read mention Google’s June 2026 hiring-page changes. Treat the counts as brainstorming, not benchmarks.
The Signing Key: how to score each answer
Score 0 for an evasive or red-flag answer, 1 for an acceptable but generic answer, and 2 for a specific answer you can verify in under ten minutes. Total the 12 scores, then read the result against this key.
| Total score | Meaning | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| 20 to 24 | Specific answers on most questions | Sign, with the exit clause you were promised in writing |
| 14 to 19 | Mixed: some answers are generic | Re-ask every 1-point question by email and re-score; negotiate a 90-day exit |
| 0 to 13 | Mostly evasive or templated | Do not sign; take the shortlist to the next agency |
| Any 0 on questions 1 to 3 | Ownership, access or guarantee problem | Stop, whatever the total |
Thresholds are GCL Marketing’s own rubric, not an industry standard.
What changed in Google’s hiring guidance in 2026
Google updated its Do you need an SEO? page in June 2026 and added a separate page on third-party SEO tools, services and advice. As reported by PPC Land and Search Engine Journal, the update does four things that matter in a sales call. It tells owners to grant only read access to Search Console at the audit stage. It addresses AEO and GEO services directly and says Google does not evaluate third-party services. It notes that third-party tools lack Google’s internal ranking data. And it adds a section on reporting deceptive SEOs to the FTC. Questions 2, 6 and 7 below are built on those points.
The 12 questions, in order of cost
Each question has a strong answer, a weak answer, a check you can run in ten minutes or less, and the reason it is ranked where it is. Ownership and access come first because they cannot be undone after signing.
1. Who will own our Search Console, Analytics, Business Profile and hosting accounts, and our content?
Strong answer: Every account sits under your own login, the agency is added as a user, and written terms say the content and reports are yours if you leave.
Weak answer: Accounts are created under the agency’s login, or the answer is that it is standard practice for them to hold the property.
10-minute check: Open each account and confirm your own login is listed as owner or administrator. Five accounts, five passes.
Why it matters: Anything the agency owns, you must rent back or rebuild when you leave, and that is the most expensive mistake on this list.
2. What access do you need on day one, and at what level?
Strong answer: Read access to Search Console for the audit, with write access added later and only for a stated task. Google’s guidance says not to grant write access at the audit stage.
Weak answer: Asks for owner access to everything before any audit, or cannot say what each permission is used for.
10-minute check: Ask for a one-line reason for each permission. A strong answer takes under a minute and names the task.
Why it matters: Write access can submit sitemaps, request indexing, set crawl rates and disavow links, so it should follow a plan, not precede it.
3. Do you guarantee any ranking, traffic or AI result?
Strong answer: No guarantee of a position. Commitments are about process: audit, deliverables, reporting dates. Any refund or exit term is written down.
Weak answer: A promised number one position, a promised date, or a claim of a special relationship with Google. Google says no one can guarantee a number one ranking.
10-minute check: Ask them to put the guarantee in the contract. Evasion on paper is your answer.
Why it matters: A guarantee usually means easy keywords with little qualified traffic, or tactics that put the site at risk.
4. What will you change in the first 30 days, in order?
Strong answer: A named list tied to your own data: for example fix indexing on key pages, rewrite titles on the top ten landing pages, add one missing service page.
Weak answer: An audit PDF, a keyword list, or the phrase foundation work with no pages, dates or owners.
10-minute check: Count the items that name a specific URL or template. Fewer than three is a generic plan.
Why it matters: The first month shows whether the plan comes from your site or from a template.
5. Show me the Search Console data behind one past result for a business like mine.
Strong answer: A date range, the queries or pages that moved, clicks and conversions, and what was changed. The agency says which numbers are self-reported.
Weak answer: A rankings screenshot, a percentage with no base number, or the answer that client data is confidential with no redacted example offered.
10-minute check: Ask for the starting and ending clicks, not only the percent. If they cannot give both, score 0.
Why it matters: A percentage without a base can describe 4 clicks becoming 12, which is a 200 percent gain and no business result.
6. Which Google documents does your advice rely on, and where do you disagree with them?
Strong answer: Cites Google Search Essentials or the relevant Search Central page by name, and labels anything else as opinion from experience.
Weak answer: Says Google prefers something with no source, or claims a tool or service is Google-approved. Google says it does not evaluate third-party services.
10-minute check: Pick one recommendation and ask where Google says it. A strong team finds the page or says it is judgment.
Why it matters: Google’s June 2026 update to its hiring page asks exactly this about SEO, AEO and GEO advice.
7. How will you measure our visibility in AI answers, and what can you not measure?
Strong answer: Names the method (tracked prompt set, citations, referral data), the sample size, and admits results vary run to run and are not Google data.
Weak answer: A single AI visibility score with no method, or a guarantee of citations. Google notes third-party tools lack access to its internal ranking data.
10-minute check: Ask how many prompts are tracked and how often. If the answer is not a number, score 0.
Why it matters: AEO and GEO are the newest line items on proposals and the easiest to oversell.
8. If we cancel, what is the notice period, what do we keep, and what happens to the pages and links?
Strong answer: A stated notice period, ownership of all content and documents on exit, and a handover of working files within a set number of days.
Weak answer: A long lock-in with no exit clause, fees for handover, or content that the agency keeps.
10-minute check: Ask for the exit clause in writing before the call ends. Then run the exit math below.
Why it matters: Contract length is the number that turns a mistake into a bill.
9. Who does the work, and is any of it outsourced or done by AI without review?
Strong answer: Names the roles, says which tasks are outsourced, and says who reviews every deliverable before it reaches your site.
Weak answer: Only a senior person is named in the sale, and the answer on outsourcing is that the team handles everything.
10-minute check: Ask to meet the person doing the weekly work. If that is refused, score 0.
Why it matters: Quality drifts when the seller and the doer are different people.
10. What does the first report look like, and which number should move by day 90?
Strong answer: Shows a sample report with leads, calls or revenue next to Search Console clicks, and names one leading indicator for day 90 such as indexed pages or impressions.
Weak answer: A rankings list, a traffic total only, or the answer that SEO takes time with no checkpoint.
10-minute check: Ask what number would make them tell you the plan is not working. A strong team has one.
Why it matters: A report that cannot show a miss cannot show a win.
11. What would you say no to, and what kind of clients do you turn down?
Strong answer: Gives a real example: a client with no budget for content, a site that needs a rebuild first, a request for link buying.
Weak answer: Says yes to everything, including tactics that break Google’s spam policies or requests to link to them.
10-minute check: Ask for one task they would refuse on your site. Hesitation is data.
Why it matters: An agency that never says no will sell you something you do not need.
12. Who is my day-to-day contact, and how many accounts do they carry?
Strong answer: A named person, a number of accounts, and a stated response time.
Weak answer: No number, or a contact who changes after signing.
10-minute check: Ask for the number out loud. Compare it with what a single person can review in a week.
Why it matters: Attention is the real deliverable on a retainer.
Run the ownership check before the first call
Do this ten-minute test before you talk to any agency: open Search Console, Analytics, your Business Profile, your domain registrar and your hosting, and confirm your own login is the owner or administrator in each. Five of five is a pass. Anything less means a prior vendor or developer holds a key, and you should fix that first so no new agency can inherit it by default.
The exit math most lists skip
A contract length is a dollar figure, and you can calculate it before you sign. This worked example is hypothetical, with round numbers, and shows why question 8 matters.
| Hypothetical contract at $2,000 a month | You cancel after month 3 | Total paid |
|---|---|---|
| 12-month term, no exit clause | Still owe months 4 to 12 | $24,000 |
| 90-day exit, 30 days notice | Pay through month 4 | $8,000 |
| Difference | $16,000 |
Hypothetical numbers for illustration, not a quote and not a client result. A shorter term may carry a higher monthly rate, so ask for both prices.
See how much SEO costs in 2026 for published price ranges to plug into the same math.
Where we disagree with the common advice
Two popular tips are weaker than they look. First, asking how many years an agency has operated or which tools it uses tells you little, because both are easy to answer well and neither predicts whether your site gets fixed. Second, treating month-to-month as always safer ignores that SEO often needs a quarter to show movement, so a monthly term can end a working plan early. We would rather you ask for a 90-day exit with full handover than demand no commitment at all. Our case study is a single home services marketing agency result, self-reported, so ask us the same twelve questions.
When this list is the wrong tool
Skip the full list if you cannot state a goal such as qualified leads or booked jobs, because no answer can be scored against nothing. Skip it too if you only need a one-time fix: use questions 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 and 8 and buy a project, such as the audit and fixes listed under our services. If the shortlist is not set, the local SEO agency scorecard and our guide to link building agencies show the same disclosure approach applied to named firms.
FAQ: questions to ask an SEO agency
How many questions should I ask an SEO agency?
Ask all 12 in one structured call, then score the answers. The first three decide whether to continue: ownership, access and guarantees. For a one-time audit, those three plus questions 4, 5 and 8 are enough. More than 20 questions usually produces notes, not decisions.
What is the biggest red flag when hiring an SEO agency?
A guaranteed ranking. Google states that no one can guarantee a number one position and says to find someone else if an SEO promises it. Close behind are claims of a special relationship with Google and any request that you link to the agency.
Should I give an SEO agency access to Google Search Console?
Yes, but start with read access. Google says to grant only read access to Search Console for an audit and not write access at that stage. Write access can submit sitemaps, request indexing and disavow links, so add it later for a named task.
Is a month-to-month SEO contract always safer?
Not always. A month-to-month term lowers your exit cost, but SEO takes months to show, so cancelling early can end a plan before it works. A 90-day minimum with a 30-day notice and full handover is a fair middle for many buyers.
Where can I report a deceptive SEO company?
In the United States, Google points to the Federal Trade Commission, which takes complaints online or at 1-877-FTC-HELP. Outside the US, Google points to econsumer.gov. Google added this reporting section to its hiring guidance in 2026, so it is a recent option.
Print the 12 questions, score each agency on the same page, and keep the written answers with the contract. If you want to see how the work fits together, visit us at GCL Marketing.